danwtmoon

UPDATE

So in the last 24 hours I made a conscious effort to use and fall in love with Foursquare... I didn't. I became a mayor and got some more badges.... Yay...

The thing is badges just aren't anywhere near the social currency of a card in Flook for example... My friend @reyes said it best:

"Finding myself learning more and more about London as I hunt out the perfect flook" - http://twitter.com/reyes/status/7786945085

Also theres this from @nicolariordan - "I've found some great hidden pubs and restaurant near me with it"

Flook cards are more analogous to the human conversation around location... I don't ever remember texting or calling people to "checkin" and if I did I'm pretty sure they'd respond "are you drunk and / or why do I care?"

And so today, despite me picking up another snazzy badge from Foursquare (http://foursquare. com/user/danwtmoon/badges/506207), I'm deleting the app and focusing on location browsing.

--- original post: ----

Being going through an early spring clean across all areas of life recently... I've previously blogged about my app cleanup on iPhone taking me down to ~50 from ~120...

Since then I've been in the frame of mind of only retaining apps that I am actually using most, if not all, days for more value than just because I can...

Today Foursquare is under close scrutiny... I've previously had Brightkite, Rummble, Gowalla, Foursqaure and Flook all on my iPhone. today I have only Flook and Foursqaure.

Short background of the others history is that Rummble has a UI that causes me tears and is too buggy (shame as having met @andrewjscott, I know the guy is smart and passionate but unfortunately doesn't have an infinite army of developers to execute what on paper is a good product); Brightkite has gone the way of the dodo given I don't see value of pure checking in and so Gowalla / Foursquare killed it; Gowalla was preferred over 4sq until they went *everywhere*...

Flook has been omni-present on my iPhone since being on the beta.

So 4sq is under scrutiny today.. I'm going to take extra care to checkin everywhere and look for tips... At the end of the day if I feel better for it then it will stay... If not it goes and leaves on Flook. I found it interesting that @scobleizer seemed to praise 4sq becuase of tips... Well with 4sq, at least in LDN, there's very little tipping and if that's what floats your boat Robert then Flook is just the tip part of 4sq minus the novelty of checking in..

Flook FYI is under no threat at all. It's the perfect location app and the reason I state this as fact is that it has no hype.. You know what I mean? All the hyped products suffer because actually their biggest selling point was promise from the hype not the *actual* product.
Looking at my twitter stream I see people like @reyes flooking away and genuinely getting value of the awesome location browser. Do I see love for the novelty of checking in and being a mayor? No

So Flook rocks (if you have iPhone get from app store / http://flook.it and 4sq is under threat...
I'm checking out of checking in

Loading mentions Retweet